All About Symbian - News from the Symbian Ecosystem...

Nokia Q1 2010 results, smartphone growth with cautious outlook

Published by Rafe Blandford at 12:27 BST, April 22nd 2010

Nokia has released their Q1 2010 results, reporting an operating profit of €488 million, with net sales €9.5 billion (up 3% YoY). Nokia's device and service division's profits were €831 million, up 52% year on year. Margins in devices and services were 12.1% (up 1.3% YoY and down 5% QoQ). Converged devices sales (smartphones) were 21.5 million, compared with 13.7 million units in Q1 2001 (up 57% YoY) and 20.1 million units in Q4 2009 (up 3%). As such, worldwide smartphone marketshare was 41%, up 1% sequentially and 3% year on year. Full story and comments below.

Nokia's results are below market expectations; analysts were expecting a larger increase in profits and a more optimistic outlook. Nokia has projected lower than forecasted devices and service margins in the year ahead (and its forecasts for Q2 were cautious in general). These factors are the primary contributors to a falling share price this morning.

Nokia has been squeezed in the low end device market (Series 40). However, the results in the key smartphone segment are encouraging, with increased shipments and marketshare (beating the overall market average). There were also encouraging signs for Ovi Maps (10 million downloads), and continued growth from Ovi Store (9,500 content items for key devices, average active user downloads 8 items per month).

Olli-Pekka Kallasuvo, Nokia CEO, said:

"In Q1, Nokia delivered both year-on-year net sales and operating profit growth. We continue to face tough competition with respect to the high end of our mobile device portfolio, as well as challenging market conditions on the infrastructure side.

During the quarter, we also demonstrated our ability to deliver the Nokia smartphone experience to consumers on a global scale, with our smartphone shipments up by more than 50% year-on-year. The consumer response to the inclusion of our walk and drive navigation offering on our smartphones has been tremendous. Since launching in January, 10 million Nokia smartphone users around the world have downloaded the offering.

In infrastructure, Nokia Siemens Networks’ profitability benefited from a positive sales mix in Q1. I am also pleased to see encouraging results from the company’s focus on helping operators meet the challenge of the rapid growth in data and signaling traffic from smartphones."

As part of the release Nokia notes that:

"Nokia is planning to deliver a family of smartphones based on the Symbian^3 software platform that is targeted to offer a clearly improved user experience, a high standard of quality, and competitive value to consumers. We plan to launch the first smartphone based on Symbian^3 during the second quarter 2010, with shipments expected during the third quarter 2010."

This is being widely reported as a delay in introducing the first Symbian^3 handsets (initially expected to arrive on the market at the end of Q2), with some justification. Nokia did say they would deliver 'a major product milestone before mid-year 2010'. It is worth noting that both Nokia and Symbian have been careful not to be too specific about dates. Symbian's own roadmap says devices are expected in H2 2010.

On the conference call Nokia indicated that the Symbian^3 release was behind its internal plan. OPK noted that they would not ship the first Symbian^3 device 'before the quality meets the demand of the end user' and that it 'will improve our position in the high end' and that are 'very confident' about the Symbian^3 device portfolio.

The reality is there's a small time delay to Nokia's Symbian^3 device; it would appear to be a matter of weeks. However this does have a significant impact on Nokia's financial results (in Q2, Q3) and portfolio mix. The delay will impact the first device most, subsequent devices will be delayed much less (the platform advantage).

Nokia also indicated that it has shifted the planned introduction of Symbian^4 based products to 2011. Nokia continues to expect to deliver its 'product milestone' for its first MeeGo device by the end of the year.

See more earnings call comments below.
   

Points of interest  

  • Nokia mobile device volumes were 107.8 million units, up 16% year on year and down 15% sequentially (not unusual for Q1, which follows the holiday market). This is set against estimated industry volumes of of 323 million units, up 11% year on year and down 10% sequentially. Nokia's overall (phones) market share was 33%, up 2% from Q1 2009 and down 2% from Q4 2009 (note: Nokia recently changed the way in calculates market share).

    Average selling price was EUR 62, down from EUR 66 in Q1 2009 and down from EUR 64 in Q4 2009. Nokia says this was mainly due to price erosion and the decline was slightly offset by a higher proportion of smartphone sales. The year on year change was partly the result of a greater proportion of lower end smartphone sales.
      
  • Converged device shipments (smartphones) were 21.5 million (up from 20.8 million in Q4 2009 and 13.7 million in Q1 2009). The year-on-year increase in smartphone sales was 57%, reflecting improving economic conditions and a broader smartphone portfolio. Nokia did not release a breakdown of Nseries and Eseries sales (we have estimated them on the graph below). 
      
  • Converged device ('smartphone') marketshare was 41%, up 1% sequentially and 3% year on year. Estimated global market volume was up to 52.6 million from 36 million year on year and 52.4 million sequentially. This means Nokia's smartphone sales outgrew the market average. However, as we've mentioned before, sequential figures do tend to be quite variable, due to the fact that big individual launches can still have an impact on the relatively small smartphone market. 

  • Ovi Maps with free navigation has been downloaded 10 million times.
      
  • More than 3 million Nokia Messaging accounts have been created.

  • The most popular devices in Ovi Store have access to 9,500 items of content, operator billing is available with more than 60 operators and the average active user is downloading around 8 applications/content items per month.

Q1 2010 update

Nokia smartphone shipments in recent quarters.
N.B. Eseries, Nseries, Numbered are estimated for Q1 2010
as Nokia has not released these numbers separately. 

Notes from the earning call

  • 18 million touch and QWERTY devices shipped last quarter.

  • Top 8 converged mobile devices (smartphones) were all touch and/or QWERTY devices.
      
  • More than 8 million Ovi Mail accounts.
       
  • 72 operators deals with operators for Nokia Messaging (52 now active), 3 million accounts.
       
  • 1.7 million downloads per day in Ovi Store.
      
  • With regards to our furst Symbian^3 device. We will not ship the device before it is ready. We intend to improve our position at the high end of the market. We are confident. The date when we ship the first Symbian^3 device will have an impact on our 2010 number and our outlook reflects this. 
    OPK on Symbian^3 device: "With regards to our first Symbian^3 device. We will not ship the device before it is ready. We intend to improve our position at the high end of the market. We are confident. The date when we ship the first Symbian^3 device will have an impact on our 2010 number and our outlook reflects this."

    Later on he added, "We will not ship the product before the quality meets the demand of the end user. It is [a delay] painful, but it is the right thing to do and is in everybody's interest." 

    In responding to a question about confidence in the Symbian^3 products OPK remarked upon the feedback from partners who are working on the product with Nokia. It was noted that the operator ranging KPI (key performance indicator) for the Symbian^3 products is very positive. 

  • Initially Symbian^3 products will 'relatively high end'. However this will change over time. Other versions of Symbian will continue (e.g. C6, E5 type products).
       

Rafe Blandford, AAS, 22 April 2010

See also

Nokia Results

Earlier results: Q4 2009Q3 2009Q2 2009Q1 2009Q4 2008Q3 2008, and Q2 2008

Categories: Industry, Editorial Thoughts
Platforms: General, S60 3rd Edition, S60 5th Edition

News Discussion

Brendan Donegan
"This represents a delay in introducing the first Symbian^3 handsets, which were initially expected to arrive on the market at the end of Q2."

NO! It does not represent a delay - because no-one ever said they would be introduced by Q2 2010.

Here's the roadmap (this revision is from February):

http://developer.symbian.org/wiki/index.php?title=Symbian^3&oldid=42404

It clearly says 'Handsets from H2 2010'.
snoFlake
Nokia shares - 13% post announcement, Apple +14% : whilst you may deride the markets long term predictive abilities it`s ability to forecast the each companies future profitability over the last 3 quarters has been absolutely correct. After all Apple make the same revenue selling only 8.7m phones. Also the falling average handset price demonstrates that Nokia have only been able to succeed by pushing out cheaper low end devices (I would love to see comparative figs for YoY and QoQ smartphone average handset prices.

Yes the 1% smartphone growth to 41% is positive but relying soley on the bottom end is playing with fire given wave of Android and possibility of iPhone Nano.

Nokia desperately need to reoccupy the higher end and I think the N97 is going to haunt them here.
Mr Mark
Interesting and positive results. Also good to see Nokia admitting that they don't have anything to compete against the iPhone and the new Android handsets at the high end. I'm sure they will have come year end but that's the truth of the matter just now.

Nokia obviously realise this and are claiming the low to mid tier market just now. As we all know, the high end market is a precarious one and driven by fashion - what's hot one year isn't the next as the RAZR and N95 have found out - so this makes sense.

As for the analysts, first they get Q4 2009's forecast wrong by underestimating it and then Q1 2010's forecast wrong by overestimating - not to mention the complete balls up they made of Apple's numbers! Do they actually know what they're doing?
Unregistered
3 things spring to mind from reading this:

1.) Good that they have increased market share yet again. Yet more proof, if any were needed, that those saying the Nokia/Symbian/S60 was/is in any way in decline are talking utter rubbish as usual. US tech blogs, and iPhone and Android fanboys, I'm looking at you.

2.) Competitively, at the high end, Nokia are in a little bit of a lull right now - a gear change, or a pit stop for a tyre change. We're between the last bunch of high end Nokia smartphone releases last year and the next super-charged Symbian^3 smartphones. Obviously while they're in that pit stop, competitors gain ground on Nokia, it's obvious and expected. No big deal.

3.) I take note of Brendan Donegan's comment above that there has been no delay, and either way I am glad that Nokia is taking the time to get it's next crop of smartphones right. If they have decided to beef things up in certain areas to be more competitive, or decided to take a bit of extra time to ensure the new releases are as shiny and good as they can be, that's all fine with me (in contrast to the whingers after the release of the C-series the other day). Nokia have more than enough market share and installed base to afford to take time getting things right, as we have seen from them growing market share during this competitive pit-stop. It is certainly also good that they are full steam ahead on service improvements and delivery (e.g. free nav, ovi store improvements etc) as software is a more fast-paced arena.
Rafe
I have updated the story to reflect the delay issue. To be fair OPK has just said on the conference call that Nokia's Symbian^3 device is behind the internal schedule for this. We are only talking about a few weeks (6-ish maybe) - and it just happens to be at the end of a quarter...

snoFlake - agreed - market is good short term, but performance is not the same as long term strategy (as we have both said in past). I think you can see that all players in this market have stuff coming up that is going to be both positive and negative...
Brendan Donegan
I don't know anything about what goes on inside Nokia (not really true, but certainly nothing to do with device release schedules), but I was just pointing out that our *public* roadmap has had H2 as the estimate for quite some time. When do Apple plan to release the new iPhone? I wager it's no earlier than the end of June.
Unregistered
You didn't look at the geographical split. Nokia dominate in Africa and Latin America. In the other more important markets they aren't doing too well. :(
Unregistered
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unregistered View Post
Nokia dominate in Africa and Latin America. In the other more important markets they aren't doing too well. :(
Really? Seems they're doing pretty well to me, if you read the relevant sections of the doc. They had a 27% fall Year on Year in North America, but so what, the US is a minor mobile market globally (despite the amount of hype and hot air coming out of there) and Nokia traditionally doesn't do well in the US. APAC fell 3% too but again so what, Nokia practically own the region - even in smartphones alone Symbian devices (mostly Nokia) command over 80% smartphone market share there!
And every other region saw growth between 2% and 42%. That's not "aren't doing too well". :)
Unregistered
This just shows Nokia needs high end phones, low and middle ware phones just don't cut it when it comes to revenue and profit.

Nokia are leading the market share but low end phones have razor thin margins, just compare this to the iPhone (inevitable), sold only 8.7 million units this quarter but made US$ 5.78 billion in revenue close to half of Nokia's total and this from nothing in only 3 years!

High end phones have high margins and buyers are more willing to spend money on applications and services.

Nokia needs to release mind-blowing new Symbian 3 phones soon.

I hope they do, but right now Nokia are off my buying list, and most of the people I know with disposable income.
Unregistered
I find it very hard to sympathize with Nokia after the N97 debacle. Nokia's "high-end" flagships have been hobbled by some extremely poor engineering choices. And far from fixing those problems, they continue to perpetuate designs based on underpowered chips with inadequate memory - witness the new C series. It's as if they insist on passing off those outdated components - even to high-end consumers -hoping no one notices the inferior performance. This has everything to do with leadership and management decision.
Jimmy1
I won't kick Nokia while they're down (the stock), but I will say that they're pinning all their hopes to Symbian 3 for a turn-around. They better hope it works out for them; another N97/E72 type of experience will surely doom them to scratching out some kind of a profit on throwaway low end phones.

My i8910 running S60v5 is only still around due its fantastic camera and great video playback, but it very likely is my last Symbian device. If I go with Nokia, it will only be with something running Meego, if it finally starts actually shipping that is.
Mr Mark
Making over a billion dollars a quarter profit from their handset division isn't 'scratching a profit'.

Nokia will not be changing their low/mid tier strategy - why should they? It clearly works. Symbian^3 is about getting some of the high end back and, frankly, I'd rather wait until they get it right.
snoFlake
Looking at market cap, profitability and cash reserves rather than rumoured bid for ARM Apple should take over Nokia - instant low end portfolio and developing nation penetration and really great new open source OS :D
Unregistered
Been waiting for almost 2 years for Nokia to go bust. Guess what? It hasn't happened!!! Profit is profit no matter how you cut it. That they are able 2 maintain market share without being able to compete at the high-end, doesn't that tell you something about their strenght? The high-end devices will come! What is it about that, that you don't understand? You keyboard analysts are just so full of yourselves!
Ian 2
"We will not ship the product before the quality meets the demand of the end user."

Judging by the N97's road to acceptable quality they may release Symbian^3 phone late 2011 :) Or never...
Rafe
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unregistered View Post
I find it very hard to sympathize with Nokia after the N97 debacle. Nokia's "high-end" flagships have been hobbled by some extremely poor engineering choices. And far from fixing those problems, they continue to perpetuate designs based on underpowered chips with inadequate memory - witness the new C series. It's as if they insist on passing off those outdated components - even to high-end consumers -hoping no one notices the inferior performance. This has everything to do with leadership and management decision.
I think that why they made a statement saying Symbian^3 devices will only come when ready. That's a strong signal to me.

Quote:
Originally Posted by snoFlake View Post
Looking at market cap, profitability and cash reserves rather than rumoured bid for ARM Apple should take over Nokia - instant low end portfolio and developing nation penetration and really great new open source OS :D
One might almost think you were trying to wind up two sets of people at the same time... Mutually Assured Destruction? :D

Quote:
Originally Posted by Unregistered View Post
You didn't look at the geographical split. Nokia dominate in Africa and Latin America. In the other more important markets they aren't doing too well. :(
I didn't, but there's not really a lot there that can't be explained by a) seasonality (Christmas, Chinese New Year) b) improving economic conditions (YoY results) c) small bases (for the larger percentage numbers).
rafiii
I don't care if they need four more weeks to finish the OS and the smartphone, but please, just make it good, without bugs (or at least without the obvious ones).
Unregistered
How it is possible, that Nokia 2010 Q1 market share is ca. 33% and it's up from last Q1, but it was 37%.

What is the new method to count market share?
morpheus2702
The year-on-year growth in smartphones is very encouraging on the face of it. But as Symbian^1 devices work their way down the Nokia portfolio is it that surprising. Imagine a year from now where S60 devices have all but supplanted S40 handsets, will the majority of their shipments be 'smartphones' with requisite impressive numbers?

Not that I wish to spark any debate into what is or is not a smartphone, but if all Nokias become smartphones by default, does this not warrant a more detailed segmentation of Nokias smartphone numbers? It would be a good marketing ploy for Espoo to say that a year hence, EVERY Nokia is a smartphone?
ming387
I think it is important to point out that Nokia isn't really gaining new market shares. It more like converting people who used the S40 (dumb phone) user to S60 through their competitive pricing.

I the near future, phones will not be labeled as smart vs dumb, but more as in "high" vs "mid" and 'low' tier phones.

Nokia will make every phone a smart phone going forward simply by making them affordable; the division and analysis of smart vs dumb phone breakdown is going to blur.
Unregistered
Yipee more Nokia news!!!!

I wonder how they dismiss news of Google Maps with voice navigation is now avaiable in the UK for all android 1.6 devices and above.
Unregistered
Nokia still produces crap phones, period

Crap phones are ok for Africa and Latin America.

Well done Nokia!
UnInterested
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unregistered View Post
Nokia still produces crap phones, period

!
Period ?

Nah. Bullshit.
Unregistered
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unregistered View Post
Yipee more Nokia news!!!!

I wonder how they dismiss news of Google Maps with voice navigation is now avaiable in the UK for all android 1.6 devices and above.
Have Google fixed the ridiculous maps having to be downloaded problem yet?

Any good sat nav device has a stored internal map. Any device that doesn't is useless out of connection area.
Unregistered
I found out Apple they sell iphone with very hight profit margin. nokia seem very fairly play with user, sell with a low profit margin, It's worth to use nokia, also offer a rich free application for nokia user too.

so i feel iphone is cheating user

Full thread: 43 Comments / Post New Comment

Copyright Notes || Contact Us || Privacy Policy (Ellie)