Analysis, tutorials and tips for your Nokia and Samsung Phones

Ovi Store – A discussion with Eric John

Published by Richard Bloor at 8:22 UTC, March 31st 2009

Ovi store is expected to launch in a few weeks, ahead of the release of the Nokia N97, and become available on millions of existing S60 and Series 40 devices from Nokia. I caught up with Eric John, Director of Media Product Marketing for Nokia Services, to discuss the developer proposition offered by Ovi store.

Richard: Hi Eric, thanks for finding time to talk about Ovi Store. Can we start with the big question: Will Ovi Store work when Nokia’s earlier attempts at on-device sales portals have been perceived as less than totally successful?

Eric: We have been learning about selling software in a mobile environment through initiatives such as Download! These initiatives have been successful, but we always want to do better. Ovi Store is the result of that learning and I believe will achieve significant success in growing the market for software on Nokia devices.

One of the challenges in selling software for mobile devices is making it discoverable. A key value proposition in Ovi Store is that it leverages the unique features of Ovi and Nokia’s devices to introduce new methods of discovery. So users can find out about the software their trusted Ovi contacts have purchased or receive recommendations based on their location. So, if you travel from New Zealand to Los Angeles, Ovi Store can offer you software travel guides to Los Angeles. If you have a friend who made the same journey recently you could check their software purchases and find out if they recommend a specific guide.

This makes Ovi store significantly different from your typical mobile software website; where you either get a confusing plethora of stuff, where you can never find what you want, or a narrow list of software, that does not include what you want.

This difference is also going to be supported by scale, while the Nokia N97 will be the first device to feature Ovi Store, it will be progressively rolling out on the more than 200 million devices running Download!

So we believe that Ovi Store will offer a new and unique approach to content discovery which, because it is relevant to the user, will drive new software sales and at the same time have the volume to offer developers meaningful revenues.

Richard: So will the store only be available as an on device portal?

Eric: There will be an XHTML version of the store that will support credit card purchases to compliment the embedded device version that supports carrier billing. At launch we expect to have operator billing supported in eight countries.

Richard: Will it cover Series 40 devices too?

Eric: Yes, there will be a store for Series 40 to complement the S60 offering. These will be the main two platforms we support, but you should look out for other announcements in the future.

Richard: What criteria does software submitted to Ovi Store have to fulfil? Will Nokia be vetting titles?

Eric: Any content that can be Symbian Signed or Java Verified will need to be. So we will be supporting any content that can be packaged in one of these formats, so we can easily include Python applications, for example, in addition to Symbian C++ and Java applications.

We will also be accepting content that does not need signing, such as WRT widgets.

Flash content will also be supported by the store and we expect our recently announced ten million dollar Open Screen Project - Developer Fund initiative, which we are undertaking with Adobe, will contribute to the Flash content. Flash application packages for Series 40 will be another exception when it comes to signing.

Ovi Store is a managed service, so developers and content will be vetted. For developers the key criteria for entering Ovi will be that they are a bona fide business, so when they register we will require a business ID appropriate for their home territory, generally this will mean a tax ID — so we can be certain revenue will be treated correctly for tax purposes. They can be a big business or a solo developer: As long as they have a business ID, everyone is welcome.

In terms of content, we will only be vetting to ensure content is appropriate and of a suitable quality. When I say appropriate, I’m meaning that content should not be offensive or in poor taste: We are not in the business of limiting innovation and competition.

Richard: You have indicated that several operators will integrate Ovi Store with their billing – how will this affect the publicised 70/30 revenue split?

Eric: I believe we have been clear that the revenue split is after operator billing charges and any applicable taxes. Typically operator billing charges will be around forty per cent of the purchase price. However, this needs to be considered against the fact that operator billing offers a seamless purchase process to the user. This normally results in a higher level of sales compared to credit card purchases.

Richard: Despite the benefits of using operator billing, some developers may want to compensate for what they see as a loss of revenue, will they be able to do that?

Eric: Developers are able to pick the price at which their application sells, and that will be the price to consumers whether they choose to buy with a credit card or via operator billing. Developers can however choose which markets to sell into, they could make their application available exclusively for credit card based purchases or choose to sell exclusively via operator billing or use both channels.

It's a question of how much reach the developer wants to give their application. I certainly think that the ease-of-use and user acceptance of operator billing easily outweighs any perception of lost revenue from paying for the operator’s billing charges.

Perhaps the most important issue here is transparency and we plan to be open with developers about exactly what revenue splits will be taking place. I believe this is all clearly laid out in the terms and conditions, so everything is on the table. Ultimately we want to work with developers to optimise sales, get as many applications onto as many devices as possible, and help them grow their businesses.

Richard: While you have had some success in gaining the cooperation of operators, do you have concerns that you could be seen as cannibalising their software businesses?

Eric: We have been keeping our operator partners informed of the Ovi Store development as we are certainly aware that it could have been viewed negatively by them.

However, I believe we have created an offering that has quite a different value proposition to that offered by most operators. We’re looking at highlighting applications based on a user’s social connections and their location. We believe this will drive sales of applications that may not be seen in an operator’s store. In fact, I believe Ovi’s recommendation mechanism could be a catalyst to new types of applications.

Ovi Store is going to drive ARPU for operators. Ultimately the success of Ovi Store is about achieving benefits throughout the value chain.

Richard: How do you see Ovi Store catalysing new applications?

Eric: Having applications recommended by location and through social networks is new. Couple this with the ingenuity of our developer community and I know we will see new types of application emerge.

We have always supported developers through Forum Nokia. Ovi Store is part of our continued commitment to developers. Its ability to give developer’s applications worldwide exposure, coupled with the advances in device features and I’m sure we will see a whole new era of breakthrough applications.

Richard: For developers who are interested in getting involved, what is the next step?

Eric: Any developer interested can sign up at publish.ovi.com. Once their details have been reviewed, they will be given access to the publish to Ovi tool, with which they can upload applications for inclusion in Ovi Store.


As a bonus, here's a short information video, from Nokia, explaining the Ovi Store for publishers:

Categories: Interviews, Develop
Platforms: Series 60

Feature Discussion

Tzer2
Quote:
As long as they have a business ID, everyone is welcome.
I'd still like to know what happens to freeware. How do freeware authors (such as most open source collaborators) get their app onto Ovi Store?
Rafe
They can go in like everyone else. i.e. they will need a business ID. What this is varies from country to country. e.g. in some countries it may be as simple as a social security number [clarified, see below].

However this is obvisouly not ideal. I do know that Nokia are looking at this problem (specifically with open source). We'll report on this when we learn more.

This same issue exists around signing and there does now appear to be some willingness to address both of these issues. Wacth this space.
fernando20
I really don't like the sound of Symbian Signed being a must...
Tzer2
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rafe View Post
They can go in like everyone else. i.e. they will need a business ID. What this is varies from country to country. e.g. in some countries it may be as simple as a social security number.
If social security numbers are accepted, maybe they need to actually use that phrase instead of "business id". To my ears at least, the phrase "business id" makes it sound like you have to be a registered company to become a publisher.

A lot of people who create content (software, themes, wallpaper etc) may be doing it as a hobby, or even as part of their studies at university, so they wouldn't necessarily be linked to a registered company at all.
Rafe
I'm assuming social security number applies to sole trader status and only applies in some countries.
davidmaxwaterma
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tzer2 View Post
I'd still like to know what happens to freeware. How do freeware authors (such as most open source collaborators) get their app onto Ovi Store?
I think you are perhaps misusing the term 'freeware', or assuming that the authors of such are non-commercial entities. This is not the case. There are many types of freeware that are produces by companies that make money in other ways. Freeware just means software that is free.

Yes, I would also like to know what how they intend to minimize the expense incurred by individuals who give away software and who aren't commercial entities - ie they don't have a business id. One example of such a person might be one who develops software as a hoby. Clearly they don't want to go to all the hassle of becoming a business.
davidmaxwaterma
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tzer2 View Post
If social security numbers are accepted, maybe they need to actually use that phrase instead of "business id". To my ears at least, the phrase "business id" makes it sound like you have to be a registered company to become a publisher.

A lot of people who create content (software, themes, wallpaper etc) may be doing it as a hobby, or even as part of their studies at university, so they wouldn't necessarily be linked to a registered company at all.
I don't think he meant that SSNs will be accepted by the Ovi store; instead he meant to suggest that what is needed to get a 'business id' varies from country to country and in some countries anyone with an SSN can get a 'business id'.

I wonder what countries those are? It might be a good place to set up a proxy company, like an agency or something like that. :)
davidmaxwaterma
I wonder what a 'link item' is...(in the video)
Tzer2
Quote:
I think you are perhaps misusing the term 'freeware', or assuming that the authors of such are non-commercial entities. This is not the case. There are many types of freeware that are produces by companies that make money in other ways. Freeware just means software that is free.
Fair enough, let me be more specific... :-)

If someone creates high quality free content, and this person isn't a commercial entity, how do they get that content onto Ovi Store?


Quote:
I don't think he meant that SSNs will be accepted by the Ovi store; instead he meant to suggest that what is needed to get a 'business id' varies from country to country and in some countries anyone with an SSN can get a 'business id'.
If that's the case, wouldn't it be easier for Nokia to just ask for the social security number directly?

Does everyone have to at least pretend to be a business in order to publish on Ovi Store? :-)
davidmaxwaterma
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tzer2 View Post
If that's the case, wouldn't it be easier for Nokia to just ask for the social security number directly?
Easier for whom? Not for Nokia, I'd say....

Quote:
Does everyone have to at least pretend to be a business in order to publish on Ovi Store? :-)
My interpretation is that this is indeed the case, at least at the moment...

...but both are unambiguous questions. I wonder what the *real* answers are - I've heard a lot of guesses, but nothing really particularly definitive. It always seems to be "not right now, but we're working on it", or something like that.
Rafe
Yes davidmaxwaterman is correct. It would not be the ssid directly. But for self-employed individuals there should be a tax reference on their tax return (which is linked to their SSID). But this varies from county to country. That's what I meant. So yes individuals can't just sign up. However everyone should seek their own advice on this.

It's all about the tax, what might be good if Nokia allows for accounts that only allow non-commerical ('free') stuff. But at the moment I suspect Nokia are sorting out the commercial side of thing first with bigger companies as the priority. That's not what people want to hear, but ultimately the commercial stuff is what will allow the Ovi Store to work.

I will try and get some clarification on this though.

Soo.
Quote:
If someone creates high quality free content, and this person isn't a commercial entity, how do they get that content onto Ovi Store?
There's no way at the moment (short of setting up a company), but as others have noted this is probably going to change. Sorry for the confusion caused. I'd also recommend people check the Ovi Publish forum on Forum Nokia.
Tzer2
Quote:
It's all about the tax, what might be good if Nokia allows for accounts that only allow non-commerical ('free') stuff.
Yeah, that's pretty much what I didn't understand. If someone just wants to upload freeware, you'd think tax laws would be irrelevant as no money would be changing hands.
Unregistered
Can't Nokia just make developers do their own tax? Therefore offloading all responsibility off Nokia?
davidmaxwaterma
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unregistered View Post
Can't Nokia just make developers do their own tax? Therefore offloading all responsibility off Nokia?
Isn't this exactly what they've done? How else can they ensure developers declare the profits on their tax returns?

You didn't think Nokia were going to file developers' tax returns, did you?

The only alternative would be to ignore the whole issue of tax and just rely on developers behaving legally.
Jonnycat26
Do either the Apple Store or the Blackberry Store require a tax ID? I'm fairly sure the Apple store doesn't, and I'd be surprised if the Blackberry store did.

It's not just freeware developers who are going to be hurt by this... it's the small hobbyist developers who won't bother releasing software. Apple seems to cater to them, and Nokia... doesn't have a clue.
Unregistered
Looks like they don't really require business ID to register you company. At least for now. Makes no sense to require one until you make some money.
ccraig
here guys take a sneek peek at a video of OVI store app running on n85, http://conversations.nokia.com/2009/...ublish-to-ovi/
it's looking very promising i must add, I cant wait for launch
Williamoni
Quote:
Eric: We have been learning about selling software in a mobile environment through initiatives such as Download! These initiatives have been successful, but we always want to do better.
Are you having a laugh mate?

Download! is one of the most maligned systems of all time.

I'm sorry but I'm not keen on corporate spin. I get enough of it in the organisation I work for. Let's be honest about things. Correct statement would be 'Download has been rubbish - now we are doing something much better'.
Unregistered
Agreed with above. Could he have actually said that with a straight face? Amazing..
svdwal
If a developer sells software in other countries through a reseller, the reseller handles the VAT. The proceeds of the sale are also subject to income tax or other taxes, depending on the kind of business (sole trader, limited etc). The country of the reseller might take that income tax out of the money made by the developer. E.g the US government takes a 30% cut from the money made by the developer, and the reseller is obliged to take that cut on behalf of the US government.

A number of countries have signed tax treaties, meaning that the country of the developer will tax the developer and the country of the reseller won't tax the developer. You might need to do something for that, eg if you don't want the US government to tax you and your home country has a tax treaty with the US, you have to apply to the US government for a special US tax id. You won't be taxed by the US, but you will be taxed by your own country. This makes filling in your own taxes easier, and your country might have lower taxes too.

If Nokia allows selling software from an individual who isn't registered, so Nokia essentially doesn't know who the individual is, Nokia is in essence operating a money laundring scheme. The idea is to buy software with black money, and getting 70% of it back as revenue from selling mobile content. There's also the possibility of creating black money this way. Finally, people might rip of other peoples work by selling it or giving it as their own on Ovi.

20 Comments / Post New Comment

Copyright Notes || Contact Us || Privacy Policy (Ellie)