Resco Photo Viewer
The fledgling Resco Image Viewer was reviewed by Ewan back in 2006, but Steve Litchfield thinks it's high time to try out the more mature Resco Photo Viewer 5.0 on Nokia's flagship E90 Communicator.
Version Reviewed: 5.00
Score: 91
Now, I want to make it absolutely clear at the outset that if you own a Nokia Nseries phone then you don't need to read this review. The photo viewer/editor that comes with all Nseries devices is fast, efficient and will do everything you ever want it to.
However...
If you own an Eseries device, each of which comes with the appallingly outdated original S60 Gallery application, whose code dates from the Dark Ages, then Resco Photo Viewer is definitely something you should look at. I've been trying it on the Nokia E90 and have been enormously impressed.
In order to get a feel for how well this third party application does, however, we need to look at the performance and capabilities of S60 Gallery. On my E90, I snapped a few dozen 3 megapixel photos, each around 1MB. S60 Gallery handles these badly, taking up to eight seconds for each photo to load in the preview pane, and then eight more seconds to load in its own window. Sixteen seconds to view a single 1MB image is appalling. And unusable. In addition, S60 Gallery (on non-Nseries devices) doesn't have any editing functions whatsoever. I know, I know, the E90 - and E71 and E61i and E66 - have no pretensions at being multimedia workhorses, but such slow and clunky operation is downright embarrassing.
The built-in S60 Gallery. Nice enough interface, but so, oh so slooooowwwwww....
Enter Resco Photo Viewer, which presents the same images in a maximum of a second per photo and quite often with no delay whatsoever, depending on the direction you're moving through your photo collection and thus how much it has cached upcoming images. But even at worst case, it's a whopping eight times faster than S60 Gallery. And you can do more with Resco Photo Viewer, a lot, lot more....
The basic two thumbnail views are of 14 images and 44 images, with two corresponding list views, showing more information per image - for example:
And there are two browsing modes: with folders 'hidden' (the default), in which every image on your device is aggregated together, and with folders shown, in which case you browse through the folder structure on your phone's disks manually.
It all adds up to a flexible arrangement. At any point, you can blast into an optimised slide show of the relevant photos by pressing '0', one of a large number of numeric shortcuts in Resco Photo Viewer - although the shortcuts take a bit of memorising, there are always equivalent 'Options' menu commands, and the shortcuts are always shown beside the plain English versions.
The slideshow itself works very well, with 'blinds' transitions between each image and switches every 5 seconds by default, but you can change absolutely everything in 'Settings', including having each image 'filling' the screen, useful on the wide screened-E90. You can even assign a particular music track as accompaniment, which makes for a professional looking presentation to show to friends and family.
Once an image is on the screen, the same options as for the regular Gallery are present (Send/Rotate/Wallpaper/Add to Contact), plus a variety of zooming and fit/fill options, a 'Mirror' function, plus Negative and colour adjustment screens. These latter are very impressive, with a childishly simple interface making easy work of adjusting brightness, contrast, colour saturation, red, green and blue components.
The range of image types supported is wide, including JPEG2000, Tiff/Fax, MBM and others. Significantly, for people who really want to kick the native S60 image routines into touch, you can specify in Settings whether you want Resco Photo Viewer to handle any of these file types on behalf of the OS. A powerful option.
Extras include being able to jump from geotagging information in a photo's displayed EXIF data straight to the right spot in Google Maps online. Sadly, not using an installed Google Maps/S60 installation, but using Web and the generic Maps interface - but still possibly useful and in any case it's not a core feature. Much more useful is to save the geotag position as a generic Nokia Maps/Google Maps landmark, for navigation to at a later date.
A final extra is a neat memory status dialog, useful because it gives you the amount of free RAM, a figure which you otherwise have to install an extra utility for.
It's very hard to find ways to fault Photo Viewer - with a lot of development behind it, including work specifically for the E90, any rough edges have long since been knocked off and what's left is fit, fast and functional. Yes, S60 Gallery should have included something this good - but since the Eseries seem to have been rather overlooked on this front, I'm going to take all the help I can get from a third party.
In this case, Resco Photo Viewer just earned itself a place on my 'My own' key on the E90 - and also an All About Symbian MegaApp award - with the caveat that this only applies to non-Nseries owers! If you own an E90 in particular, this is an essential purchase.
Steve Litchfield, All About Symbian, 12 October 2008
Share This (Digg, del.icio.us, Facebook, etc.)
Review Discussion
12 Comments / Post New Comment
srw985
N series gallery is just as bad really. Its a shame Resco dont to a video viewer so I can stop using it completely.
The Samsung i8510 has the same gallery as Eseries but also has a custom Samsung Album app, which is just as bad as Nseries gallery, so I use Resco on that aswell
Ratkat
I have to say the gallery on your E90 is very slow.
My E71's gallery takes barely a second to show both thumb and full image.
I imagine it is because the E90 3.2mp images are roughly 1MB in size, unlike the E71 which uses so much compression that images are on average barely 400k.
Unregistered
Actually browsing trough the folders on my E71 I noticed it places pics taken with camera in some sort of hierarchy of folders. There seems to be a folder for each month and,inside it, some amount of subfolders with limited images each. I think this way the gallery works smoothly (generating first preview for the few last images).
maartenmk
The feature I miss most, which prevents me from always using this on my N82 instead of the gallery is that it doesn't have high resolution output to TV.
(off-topic: the same comment applies to Coreplayer and Smartmovie)
And the main reason I prefer this over the N-series gallery is that the latter shows _all_ pictures, including those from saved web pages, or some freeware apps.
Dynite
Nokia introduced a seperate process which caches metadata such as is used by the gallery, which is making a big improvement on speed. (not sure which version this is.. 9.3/9.4 maybe)
Also, having things in seperate folders inproves the speed a lot as a FAT file system becomes very slow when the number of files in an individual folder starts to grow.
chendu
The gallery i see in my n95 8gb is one of the worst experiences and nightmare I face with it everyday. I have some 100 odd pics and it takes 3-4 minutes to just load the gallery. Completely unacceptable for a 600$ brick I got....n95 8gb is very slow and frustrating in everyway.. i try my best to support 'open' stuff like having n73, n95, n800 but with their sluggishness and after burning my fingers and pocket i am thinking of shifting to iphone so that atleast i can have something that is fast, good UI and works decently...
christexaport
chendu and srw985, I'm so glad you said what I would've been blasted for saying. Today's Nseries gallery is unchanged from my N90, which was cool then, but is sad sack now. Most Symbian Freak Nseries users prefer Resco as well. I wished the Nseries gallery supported multiple views, better image resizing, and faster loading. Both the default and Resco apps need better thumbnail management. Right now, when you delete an image, the thumbnail remains in storage, instead of automatically updating.
I, too, noticed how large folders of images load slower. It seems Nokia should employ the technology used by Lonely Cat Games X-Plore to quickly cache and load large folders. Not sure how it works, but its near instantaneous.
I think Nokia should stop developing weaknesses of the OS, such as the file browser, media gallery, multimedia player, task manager, and email client, and instead spark agreements to embed alternative apps instead, like X-Plore, Resco Viewer, LCG Jukebox, Coreplayer, Profimail, and JBak Taskman. It will raise the bar for the next solution, and give better out of the box experience, and should be possible for far under $55 per device in large volumes.
Unregistered
chendu, after reading your comment I restarted my phone (n95 8gb) and then started the gallery to gauge the speed. My phone opened the gallery in less than 10 seconds and I have 712 photos/videos. I think there may be something wrong with your phone if it is taking that long.
Unregistered
With my n95, it took 8 seconds with 608 images. chendu, are you sure you hadn't just copied some new stuff into memory? The gallery app is a bit stupid in the way that is always searches for images, would be much better if it just did what the music program does, that being, you refresh it manually. Would also be good if you could choose which folders to look for images in, but anyway.
Unregistered
If you have all your images in internal storage (real internal, not the 8GB+ internal storage), then it will be much faster. This is because internal storage is often more than twice the speed of MicroSD cards.
When you have more images than you can hold in your internal storage, then the speed of the card itself comes into play. Lots of cards are very slow - in tests deleting files, one card took 10s to delete files and another (formatted identically and with same files present) took 30s to delete the same files.
This is probably why you guys are all experiencing different speeds. You might want to try defragmenting your file system also.. Not so much for block fragmentation like hard disks, because that doesn't happen on a flash device, but directory entries on a FAT file system will benefit from being stored contiguously, allowing them to be read quicker. And since finding/opening files is a large part of the activity of a gallery-type application, it should help.
You can do this by copying all the files off, formatting the card, and then copying them back on. This trick works also for things like web browser caches etc. I think if you even just back up the contents and remove the folder and recreate it, you should see a difference.
Unfortunately, for non-removable drives you will have to backup, factory reset, and restore. It's the only way to reconstruct the internal file system.
chendu
Thanks for the suggestions guys. I will check it out. In the beginning I have formatted my 8GB memory twice to find whether that resolves the issue. I use the 8GB memory for smses apart from music and photos. Most of my apps I have it in 128 MB memory.
Unregistered
Nseries Gallery is almost as terrible as the S60 one. It doesn't support folders in the file system structure. FAIL. I've been using Resco since it's early versions and it is fantastic in all respects. The only improvement I would like to see is that the anti-aliasing of images when zoomed in/out is not as good as NSeries Gallery's.
12 Comments / Post New Comment
