All About Symbian - Symbian, Nokia and S60 unwrapped.
Review: Snaptu
Published by Ewan Spence at 20:32 UTC, February 5th 2010
Cards on the table, I always wonder just how effective applications like Snaptu actually are. They bundle up a number of web services into a single home screen, available when you launch an application, giving you quick access to sites such as Twitter, Facebook, Google Picasa and others.
I mean I know why they should be good in practice – outside of Symbian, the number of phones that can handle all these websites natively and not fall over is quite small, so having a Java-based application as a central station for the apps is a good idea for those phones.
Does it provide as much value for a Symbian smartphone, where the popular services already have widget support, third party applications or comprehensive mobile sites for using in the browser? I suspect for many power users the answer to this will be no, and they will stick with the tools that provide much wider access. The Snaptu versions of sites such as Facebook are not as functional as options that are already available on the Symbian platform.
There's also the fact this is a Java application, and one that has not been optimised for Symbian. Run it on a touch-screen device and, while you can happily interact with the on-screen dialogs and buttons, there's every chance you'll get an on-screen 'virtual' joypad and buttons taking up the bottom half of the screen. This can be switched off (Steve helpfully pointed out the route to me – App manager / Installed apps / Snaptu / Suite Settings. While you do get the functionality, it's far from a straightforward experience.
One note for Snaptu, while it's great that you can install the app on the handset either via an SMS'ed link or the on-device web browser, it would be nice if the .jar file could be downloaded via a PC – I couldn't find a link anywhere on the website. Not everyone wants to go through their phone browser to install. It's nice to have the file on the PC first, and as a backup.
Putting those thoughts aside, how well does Snaptu achieve its goal? If you were on a basic phone, then it would do it quite well, but compared to the Symbian experience, it's a success in function only – graphically it's poor and the UI handling uses the rather ugly default options.
One of the advantages that Snaptu provides is that all the various sites and services have been homogenised into a standard look and feel. Once you are comfortable using the interface to navigate Twitter, then switching to Facebook does not require any new UI knowledge (just the knowledge of how Facebook works, and it's fair to assume that users would already have this).
Given that Snaptu has a significant number of “application” icons that can be placed on its main screen, having this consistency makes the new services easily accessible. Jump from your Twitter experience to the Guardian News Feed and you get a familiar looking list of newspaper sections, which lead to clickable headlines and stories direct from the Guardian, without having to navigate through their main (or mobile) website.
These applications are managed from within Snaptu itself, and you can add more web applications and links to mobile websites either from the full catalogue that Snaptu have available, or from a smaller 'recommended' list that is provided. It's quite mainstream, but covers the main news sites (including the BBC and Reuters) as well as the popular web services - although it shouldn't be a surprise that none of the Ovi services from Nokia are included!
Being a 'standard' Java application, aiming for cross platform compatibility rears its head at almost every turn. Entering any textual info means clicking on a box and being taken to the full screen Java entry screen. And that's just ugly. The other gotcha in the Java mix is the font handling. It's not the nicest of fonts and in use I was picking up only four tweets, even on the expansive S60 5th Edition screens. There's more content on screen when looking at news sites and other text sections, such as the route finder for the London Underground, but you will have to bring the font size down to the smallest size to have something that's usable.
So here's the interesting dilemma. Snaptu does work, and does what it says on the tin. But there is no grace or fashion in the way it does it. It's blunt, hard, direct and very masculine. If that works for you (and, as a free download, it's relatively easy for you to try out), then Snaptu might be worth considering, but I've seen this idea implemented on Symbian in far nicer ways. Just because an application can run on a Symbian device doesn't mean that it should be run on a Symbian device – for lower end devices, Snaptu would be a nice alternative, but it offers nothing new to a Symbian owner who knows what they're doing on both the device and the Web in general.
-- Ewan Spence, Feb 2010.
PS. Just a quick editorial second opinion. I agree with Ewan's points, but was quite impressed by the sheer range of services that Snaptu encompassed. To gather myself the right bookmarks and widgets to mirror what Snaptu offers would take quite a while. For example, say I wanted to see what's on TV tonight. Trying to find a web-based TV guide that works acceptably in even the powerful S60 web browser is a right pain. After 30 minutes of pain, I'm sure I could find a TV listings page that was mobile-optimised, or at least not too bloated with Flash - but I also know that I could get to the right info in Snaptu in under 15 seconds. And, for that sort of occasional use, Snaptu gets my vote and is a must-install on all my phones.
Steve Litchfield
Buy Link | Download / Information Link
Review Discussion
Apart from Opera Mini, Snaptu is my main "go to" app on my phones.
I use Twitter and Facebook to quickly check for updates. It's a joy to be able to just flick in and out of each in the same app.
They're constantly adding functionality to the Twitter and Facebook clients, and I for one like the user interface. I find the (adjustable) font is very readable in all environments and screen resolutions. There's always the PC for any unsupported Facebook features that I may need to use.
The news reader is tremendouslyl handy, and it's a doddle to add new feeds (unlike Google reader say). The weather app is good too, and offers several different forecasts.
For ONE app this is an amazing array of functionality, and it's free. I know there are better individual apps for each feature, but what it's missing in functionality is more than made up for in convenience.
I would highlyl recommend that everyone just gives it a try.
(I'm not affiliated, I'm just a fan).
But for a free app, it does look like a useful one. I'll give it a try when I get the new screen on the N97.
But then again, if I hadn't my smartphone and only my old N6131, I wouldn't have dataplan and because of that not using Snaptu...
Hey, I agree with the unregistered thingy, disable these to comment. It wasn't along time ago I myself was commenting unregistered, but I felt like it is better to register and so on...
I also tried it on a new BlackBerry and had exactly the same problems.
I think it would be a great app (especially the RSS reader) but at least on wifi and at least on the 2 devices I have, it just doesn't work.
Actually snaptu it's like a must have apps on symbian smartphone. for those of you who speak malay and indonesia just login to my web. I've done an explenation in our mother language. My suggestion is make snaptu as your must have apps.
The Facebook app is so much efficient and compressive then the crappy "E71" version...
Twitter is decent is well and news feeds rock
Most impressive app & its free,its a must have !!!
i dont find it ugly....
the twitter and facebook apps do the job easily...update status, comments etc. RSS reader and i like that you can also add other "mini apps" in snaptu eg picassa....full customization....
i think Ewan's "mistake" here was he probabaly didnt use the latest version....(they update pretty regular...another plus) which also includes an integrated google search...the guys at snaptu are very informative and one can easily get responses directly from @snaptu via twitter...in a timely manner
if that is not enough...its free!
Others such as Shozu come close, but need a lot more work.
Ive used Shozu, Snaptu and Fring for a while, and Snaptu is the best designed for twitter and facebook by far.
personally, I have a BlackBerry Storm 2 and didn't bother with Snaptu as everything it did, I had an app for anyway. I don't really use Twitter, only Facebook and the rest of the stuff wasn't really necessary so I didn't see the point.
Then I started to get annoyed with the BB Facebook app, which is slow and difficult to use, so I decided to try Snaptu just for Facebook and have been delighted with the results.
Much faster and well laid out, I would recommend it over the RIM Facebook app and using the mobile site on something like Opera. The only downside is that you can't upload pics, but I can still do that through email anyway and hopefully they add that functionality soon. One other important feature is that recent versions of BB Facebook require a dataplan to work, so if you don't have a BIS or BES to access, you can't use them. Snaptu does not so Facebook access for all.
The RSS feeds are easy to use and the rest of the stuff is pretty useful, although I don't use most of them all that often. But you never know when you might need a quick way of checking TV listings or easy access to a dictionary at short notice.
why is this happening on my cellphone? isn't compatible?
thanks for the help
