The Nokia 808 PureView takes on the Samsung Galaxy Camera

Published by at

Yep, a battle royal and a sumptuous read from the GSM Arena folks. They keep an 808 around their offices as 'the gold standard in mobile phone imaging', which means that they actually know how to use it properly and aren't unduly prejudiced. Which makes a change in the tech world. In this eight page head to head they pit the 808 against a new idea in the world of photography - an Android-powered standalone camera. In this case, the Samsung Galaxy Camera. Which one won? Fair to say that it was a tussle backwards and forwards throughout all eight pages, though the 808 just edged it overall because it made more sense as a product - the Galaxy Camera makes less sense because it intrudes on DSLR price territory yet with vastly inferior output. Some quotes below.

From the GSM Arena feature's conclusion:

When we started this article we thought that the Samsung Galaxy Camera and the Nokia 808 PureView might have a lot in common - a great camera package with a smartphone OS to extend their functionality. It turns out that they are pretty different and will get different people interested.

The Galaxy Camera is great for the social networking photographers. With built-in 3G or LTE you can upload photos straight to Instagram or Facebook or Twitter or Google+ or anything really - we can't think of a popular web service that lacks Android support. Then there are things like instant upload, image editors, IM clients and everything else in the Google Play Store.

When it comes to actual camera features, the Galaxy Camera offers impressively long zoom, manual controls, as well as 60fps and 120fps slow-motion videos that are nothing short of impressive and unmatched by phones (too bad YouTube doesn't support them). It also has the best screen in the camera world - by far.

It's not all good though - the Camera is bigger than most micro four thirds and costs as much. Most disappointingly, it is miles behind them in terms of actual quality.

Nokia 808 PureView Samsung Galaxy Camera GC100 
Nokia 808 PureView • Samsung Galaxy Camera GC100

The Nokia 808 PureView, however, comes very close - readers of our blind test favored the cameraphone over an Olympus PEN E-PL2. The 808 can easily be a backup camera for keen photographers. And it fits into the smartphone category even if it has to hunch a little.

What it lacks is apps - there's no official Dropbox support, no Instagram, few custom camera UIs and image editors. Still, with working telephony on penta-band 3G and free offline SatNav, the 808 PureView can be a great companion for tourists with an interest in photography. And the not-so-rich Symbian app ecosystem manages to conjure up things like Skype, WhatsApp and Viber to save you the roaming charges.

The revolutionary Nokia 808 PureView was the last hurrah for Symbian and, while we hope its amazing sensor will make it to new Nokias, the 808 itself has almost reached the end of the line.

There's no secret we keep one in the office - as something that stands for the gold standard in mobile phone imaging...

Anyway, the Nokia 808 PureView is the smartphone equivalent of a decades-old world record. A combination of genius, inspiration and hard work - and perhaps a bit of good luck - that's just impossible to match even if all the ingredients are there. We don't think anyone was surprised at the Nokia 808 PureView getting the better of another digicam. But we won't be surprised either if connected cameras do to cameraphones what Android did to Symbian.

A well written piece, and thoughtfully illustrated too. The Galaxy Camera does seem to be more a case of Samsung trying out an idea to see how it does in the market. If Samsung was serious about the Galaxy Camera's photographic pretensions then it would have a 4/3" sensor (or similar, the Nokia 808 gets close to this) rather than the 2009-spec 1/2.3" sensor (the same size as that in the old Nokia N86). 

Now, make a Galaxy Camera 2, with bigger sensor and telephony (so that it can be used with a main SIM card for telephony via hands-free or Bluetooth or similar) and then Samsung will have something more interesting, I think....

Source / Credit: GSM Arena