Ewan
25-10-2004, 10:05 AM
Straight from CTIA in San Francisco, Nokia have announced Preminet, a storefront geared towards Operators, that will provide software, themes, ringtones and other mobile paraphernalia. Nokia will control a central catalogue, and Operators who sign up can choose which items appear in their portfolio. Brand-able client software for the user to download from the Operator. This will provide the ability to get demos of applications, and provide a payment route to be billed. But what does it all mean (http://www.allaboutsymbian.com/news.php?id=29473)?
My first thought is why strike out on your own when there are stores out there already (e.g. Digital Rivers, Handango and Power By Hand)? The key here is that Preminet only going to carry Java Certified and Symbian Signed applications. The networks, rightly or wrongly, are worried that they've put a computer into user's hands, not just a phone, and the technical support issues now are ten or twentyfold more than just "I can't dial my Gran's number." Restricting phones to a pool of pre-selected applications makes business sense to the Tech Support Department. Rest assured any Operator signing up to this is going to seriously look at locking down the phones to only running signed apps.
Most of the internet commentators have commented that this seems like Nokia is attempting to replicate Qualcomm's Brew system - which is a separate language, developer and store set-up by Qualcom for access to their phones. It's a pretty successful solution for the North American Company, but it does add in a barrier to entry for any developer of $10,000. There's no news on what Nokia will charge Developers to get listed.
Being in catalogue doesn't mean that you get distributed worldwide, it's up to the operators to decide what to put in their branded catalogue. So talk of operators being able to focus on the one relationship with Nokia, and not having to maintain relationships with hundreds of authors is, I think, a little premature. There's a lot of power being handed over to Nokia here, both in the developer hoping their choice gets pushed at a network, and in the networks giving up a lot of their independence in having what they may see as a branded Nokia Store.
And out of the shareware fee, now the Operator and Nokia have to take a cut before the developer sees any money. With Handango taking upwards of 40% in some cases, you can be sure that the big guys will want a significant portion of your money.
Finally, there's a lot Nokia trying to get everything under one roof. They've got the Developer Program (Forum Nokia), they own the main developer tool (Metrowerks' Codewarrior) and now they're gunning for the distribution system. And while this is great for Series 60 (and probably Series 80 and 90) it leaves other UI versions of Symbian OS such as UIQ marginalised. Can you see the networks running two of these stores?
That's assuming they actually go for it...
My first thought is why strike out on your own when there are stores out there already (e.g. Digital Rivers, Handango and Power By Hand)? The key here is that Preminet only going to carry Java Certified and Symbian Signed applications. The networks, rightly or wrongly, are worried that they've put a computer into user's hands, not just a phone, and the technical support issues now are ten or twentyfold more than just "I can't dial my Gran's number." Restricting phones to a pool of pre-selected applications makes business sense to the Tech Support Department. Rest assured any Operator signing up to this is going to seriously look at locking down the phones to only running signed apps.
Most of the internet commentators have commented that this seems like Nokia is attempting to replicate Qualcomm's Brew system - which is a separate language, developer and store set-up by Qualcom for access to their phones. It's a pretty successful solution for the North American Company, but it does add in a barrier to entry for any developer of $10,000. There's no news on what Nokia will charge Developers to get listed.
Being in catalogue doesn't mean that you get distributed worldwide, it's up to the operators to decide what to put in their branded catalogue. So talk of operators being able to focus on the one relationship with Nokia, and not having to maintain relationships with hundreds of authors is, I think, a little premature. There's a lot of power being handed over to Nokia here, both in the developer hoping their choice gets pushed at a network, and in the networks giving up a lot of their independence in having what they may see as a branded Nokia Store.
And out of the shareware fee, now the Operator and Nokia have to take a cut before the developer sees any money. With Handango taking upwards of 40% in some cases, you can be sure that the big guys will want a significant portion of your money.
Finally, there's a lot Nokia trying to get everything under one roof. They've got the Developer Program (Forum Nokia), they own the main developer tool (Metrowerks' Codewarrior) and now they're gunning for the distribution system. And while this is great for Series 60 (and probably Series 80 and 90) it leaves other UI versions of Symbian OS such as UIQ marginalised. Can you see the networks running two of these stores?
That's assuming they actually go for it...